A Torah Perspective On Incarceration As a Modality of Punishment and
Rehabilitation
Rabbi Sholom D. Lipskar |
Rabbi Sholom D.
Lipskar Notes
- Exodus 21:37; Leviticus 5:24; Maimonides, Laws of Stolen Property, ch. 1
- Leviticus 4; Maimonides, Laws of Transgressions, chs. 1-8
- Leviticus 20:2, 14; Deuteronomy 25:3; Maimonides, Sanhedrin, chs. 15, 17
- Exodus 12:15.
- The "Torah" is accepted by observant Jews as a collection of
Divinely-inspired 613 commandments found in the Written Law (the five books of Moses (The
Pentateuch: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy) and derivative precepts
expounded in the Oral Law (contained in writings such as the Talmud, the Code of Jewish
Law ("Shulchan Arukh") and later rabbinic rulings) (collectively, the
"Mitzvot" or "Halacha"). The Torah comprises the entire code of Jewish
conductcivil law, religious law, ritual law and ethical behavior. While many rulings
in Torah law are expounded by later rabbinic authorities, the lessons taught are believed
to exceed even the stature of their teachers. The very first paragraph of the first
chapter of the Talmuds tractate Avot states: "Moses received the Torah
from Sinai and transmitted it . . ." Except for clearly-delineated
original edicts imposed by rabbinical courts under exceptional circumstances always
to protect existent Torah rulings and never to contradict them all Torah rulings
and traditions are accepted to have originated no less at Sinai than did the Ten
Commandments. Judaism melds ethics and morality with ritual and civil law into the total
code of behavior contained in the Torah, expounded by the Sages and embodied in practice
into a living expression of G-ds Will. The eternal nature of the Torah is expressed
in the belief that no religious law may be abrogated, eliminated or compromised. The
original 613 precepts and ancillary rules remain in force and are followed wherever
possible by observant Jews even in modern times and circumstances.
- Genesis 39:20.
- Jeremiah 37:15-16, 38:4-14.
- Talmud Pesachim 91a; Talmud Yoma 11a; Talmud Sanhedrin 81b.
- Maimonides, Laws of Rotzeach ch. 4 § 8; Laws of Sanhedrin ch. 18 §§
4-5.
- Tur, Choshen Mishpat 2, Tur, Choshen Mishpat 93, no. 13.
- Halakhot Pesukot min Ha-ge'onim No. 135, Responsa Ribash 348; Rashba, vol.
2, Responsa 276, Responsa Rosh 52:8.
- See Elon, Herut ha-Perat, 172, 180-225.
- Genesis 39:20.
- Jeremiah 37:15-16; 38:4-14.
- Numbers 15:34.
- Talmud Sanhedrin 81, 2; Maimonides, Laws of Rotzeach ch. 4 § 8; Laws
of Sanhedrin ch. 18 §§ 4-5.
- Exodus 21:2; Maimonides, Laws of Slaves, ch. 1.
- Maimonides, Laws of Slaves, ch. 9.
- Numbers 35: 9-34.
- Numbers 35, 9-34; Maimonides, Laws of the Sabbatical Year, ch. 13; Laws of
Rotzeach, ch. 8.
- Deuteronomy 4:42; See Likutei Sichos by Rabbi Menachem M.
Schneerson, Portion of Vaeschannan, 5745.
- Talmud Makkoth 2:2, Encyclopedia Talmudit at 123.
- When Jewish law was not dominant, certain authoritative codifiers
sanctioned imprisonment as a deterrent and to protect society. See, e.g., Sefer
ha-Aguddah, Shabbos No. 150; Responsa Ribash No. 484; Responsa Maharash dam, Choshen
Mishpat No. 390; and Rema, Choshen Mishpat 97:15. They endorsed punishments that were
foreign to original Jewish law on one of two grounds. First, that Jewish law required one
to "eradicate the evil from your midst" (Deuteronomy 13:6; 17:7; 19:19; 21:21),
even when Torah law could not be enforced. See, e.g., Maimonides, Laws of
Rotzeach ch. 4:8-9; Laws of Sanhedrin ch. 24a). Others relied on the dictate
"the law of the land is the law." Talmud Nedarim 28a; Talmud Gittin 106; Talmud
Baba Kamma 113a; Talmud Baba Batra 54b. Even under these circumstances there were
authorities who continued to prohibit the use of jails within Jewish communities. See
Responsa Rosh No. 78:3; Responsa Rashba, vol. 1, No. 1069; Shulchan Aruch Choshen Mishpat
97:15.
- Talmud Shabbos 77b; Bereishis Rabba 44:1, 10:7.
- Talmud Berachos 60b; Likutei Torah Nasso 25c.
- Likutei Amarim Tanya, ch. 24.
- Talmud Sanhedrin, 23a.
- Likutei Amarim Tanya, Igeret HaTeshuvah, ch. 2.
- Likutei Amarim Tanya, ch. 36; Tanchuma Nasso 7, 1.
- Deuteronomy 11,13; Likutei Amarim Tanya, ch. 37.
- Talmud Avodah Zorah, 3a.
- Talmud Nedarim 28a; Talmud Gittin 106; Talmud Baba Kamma 113a; Talmud Baba
Batra 54b.
- Kesser Shem Tov 127-129.
- Maimonides, Laws of Rotzeach, ch. 6.
- Maimonides, Laws of Rotzeach, ch. 7:1.
- Id.
- Deuteronomy 4:42.
- Maimonides, Laws of Rotzeach, ch. 7:1.
- Maimonides, Laws of Repentance; Likutei Amarim Tanya, Igeret Ha
Teshuvah, ch. 1.
- Id.
- Rabah Vayikra 13:3; Rabah Bereishis 44:1.
- Eccl. 2:13; Zohar.
- Ethics of the Fathers 6:2.
- Maimonides, Laws of Kings, ch. 8.
Related Articles:
- Not Looking Forward To the Holidays: - A look at
a lost segment of our Jewish family
- Rabbi Sholom D. Lipskar and Isaac M. Jaroslawicz, Esq
- Aleph Institute's Center for Halacha and
American Law: - Questions And Answers Series
- Isaac M. Jaroslawicz, Esq
|